Ask The Science Chick: Is The Anabolic Window Real?They swear that drinking protein during this window is a mandatory part of packing anabolic window myth mass…. Download my Free Bulking Anwbolic and get a proven step-by-step boost testosterone naturally bodybuilding to quickly pack on mass and get stronger. The problem with anabolic window myth theory is that it relies only on simple logic, NOT proven science…. Windkw is so important because muscle protein synthesis is the 1 indicator of muscle growth. There is zero conclusive evidence that shows ingesting carbs and protein immediately after a workout raises muscle protein synthesis.
The 30 Minute Anabolic Window: What the Science Says | How to Beast
They swear that drinking protein during this window is a mandatory part of packing on mass…. Download my Free Bulking Routine and get a proven step-by-step routine to quickly pack on mass and get stronger.
The problem with this theory is that it relies only on simple logic, NOT proven science…. This is so important because muscle protein synthesis is the 1 indicator of muscle growth. There is zero conclusive evidence that shows ingesting carbs and protein immediately after a workout raises muscle protein synthesis. While some studies found a slight benefit, others found a bigger benefit from consuming a pre-workout meal.
This is accomplished by including simple carbs e. You see, simple carbs spike insulin levels. And spiking insulin is proven to slow muscle protein breakdown. In your case, consuming a post-workout shake with protein and simple carbs is actually quite important. It acts as one of the primary sources of energy during your workouts. And studies show you can use up a lot of your glycogen by the end of a workout.
If you want to perform at your best, get stronger, and build muscle, then you want to make sure your glycogen stores are full before every workout. Just be sure to eat enough carbs as part of your regular diet especially if you want optimal testosterone levels. After 12 weeks of lifting, there were no differences in muscle growth between the groups.
Learn the fastest way to get the body type she is proven to prefer! Not sure I agree here. The 2nd being that there is no discussion of catalyzing amino acids like leucine. You need to raise your insulin level which can be difficult unless you are training fasted. In your research, have you happened upon any related information? This is true and another reason why getting protein and carbs in immediately post-workout is not needed.
Nice to see the science to back it up. The one caveat being that it can be more comforting for certain people to eat certain ways e.
Always wondered where this myth comes from. Maybe from a study that concluded a tiny, minute difference in muscle growth that has been blown out of all proportion.
Like something an elite athlete needs to be aware of, but the average man has no use for. And yes there have been studies that have shown minute differences, and of course the one that showed higher MPB rates in fasted individuals.
I recall an interesting series of papers on how eating most of your protein in the afternoon and evening results in more lean mass gain. The proposed mechanism was lower cortisol and higher testoserone at these times. I would think eating immediately after a workout would be harmful for the same reason — large stress hormone release. The study that states that pre-workout meals can enhance muscle growth is confusing to me. Do you agree with this?
When do you eat in relation to your workouts? Honestly I think all of this research is blown out of proportion. I think the best advice I can give is to eat when it feels best for you. For me I feel best eating 2 hours before my workouts, give or take. I simply feel full if I eat any closer, or hungry if I eat and further away.
I think that this anabolic window story is a hype made of the supplement companies to promote and sell more supplements to people who are ignorant of the facts. What do you think of morning training? Do you think that there is a need for a post workout meal? My Bro goes to the gym and drinks protein shakes. His diet sucks though. A pro Rugby player wrote recently that diet is key to training, supplements are secondary. Nothing to suggest that shakes etc. I came across this article by doing a search on the postworkout meal myth.
My problem was this: This is pretty much on point. If you believe in the PWO shake so much than by all means continue to drink it. But I have a question. Here is the link: Hey Bob, the problem is that nothing is black and white when it comes to the specifics of much of exercise science, including muscle protein synthesis. For every study that concludes one thing, there will be another study that concludes the opposite. Doing this will likely drive you crazy — and most likely have a negligible difference on your actual results.
Anthony has a point David. I included them to let you know I exhausted all possible venues to see if there would be a benefit to this type of post-workout nutrition. Even when including those studies, there is no evidence.
This is interpreted from the muscle building perspective but it sounds like it applies to just recovering your muscles in sporty type activities. I mean going for an mtb ride in the morning and then doing BJJ in the evening and then the next day doing strength training for example.
When your aim is to just recover to do very strenuous activities does the same principle apply to restoring your muscles as it does to growing your muscles? In all articles that talk about magic windows and nutrient timing one tiny tiny factor is always missed. They have to hit your stomach and be digested etc. A process that takes time and is different for everybody. Today you will still be digesting heavy proteins from yesterday.
So much for the magic 30 minute windows where you have to get that brotein shake down your gullet ASAP otherwise your muscles will shrink and your next workout will suck. Same with spiking insulin with fast carbs. There may be a slight benefit if using creatine but the main part of the theory came from pro bodybuilding where insulin abuse is rife.
Your email address will not be published. The 30 Minute Anabolic Window: What the Science Says 32 comments. Share on Facebook Tweet. There's more to read: Alex on December 13, at 3: David on December 13, at 3: No not at all.
Mike on August 21, at David on August 21, at 2: Steve on December 14, at 5: David on December 14, at 6: Hey Steve, This is true and another reason why getting protein and carbs in immediately post-workout is not needed. RevLifestyleDesign on December 18, at 5: Great post, Nice to see the science to back it up. David on December 19, at 8: This is the simple truth.
Ironoak on December 20, at Great article, useful for putting this ubiquitous piece of broscience to rest. David on December 20, at 3: Illy on December 28, at 6: David on December 29, at 8: Hey Illy, this sounds intriguing. Jim on January 5, at 1: David on January 7, at Hey Jim, Honestly I think all of this research is blown out of proportion.
Jan on April 28, at 8: Damian Dareandconquer on May 7, at David, I think that this anabolic window story is a hype made of the supplement companies to promote and sell more supplements to people who are ignorant of the facts. David on May 8, at Raphael on May 11, at Dale on August 11, at Great article and good theories to back it up.